Valluvar
- Humanist or a Humanitarian?
Dr.
R. Prabhakaran
Introduction
Thiruvalluvar,
also known as Valluvar, was a Tamil philosopher who authored a remarkable book
called Thirukkual, or the Kural for short. The Kural is a classic Tamil language
text consisting of 1,330 couplets or kurals of seven words each. The
text is divided into three books with aphoristic teachings on virtue, wealth,
and love. The Kural is considered one of the greatest works ever written
on ethics and morality. In the Kural, Valluvar emphasizes equality, rationalism,
morality, ethics, love, compassion, charity, and munificence as essential virtues
to be practiced by everyone. A deep study of the Kural reveals close similarities
between the virtues emphasized by Valluvar and the modern concepts of humanism
and humanitarianism. This essay compares Valluvar’s ideas with the concepts of humanism
and humanitarianism.
Humanism
Humanism and
humanitarianism are two different philosophies. But, sometimes, people fail to grasp
the inherent differences between these two concepts and use them interchangeably
in their writings and conversations. According to the Humanist Manifesto III,
adopted in 2003, "Humanism is a progressive philosophy of life that,
without supernaturalism, affirms our ability and responsibility to lead ethical
lives of fulfillment that aspire to the greater good of humanity." Prof.
Stephen Law, a British philosopher
and senior lecturer at the University of London summarizes the basic beliefs of
humanism as follows:
·
Humanists believe that science and
reason should apply to all areas of life. No beliefs should be considered
off-limits and protected from rational scrutiny.
·
Humanists are either atheists or at
least agnostics. They are also skeptical about the existence of angels, demons,
and other such supernatural beings.
·
Humanists do not believe in
reincarnation. They also reject the existence of a soul.
·
Humanists strongly believe in the
importance of moral values. They believe that moral and ethical values are
derived from human needs and interests as tested by experience, and they should
not be based on religious values.
·
Life's fulfillment emerges from individual participation in the
service of humane ideals.
·
Humanists believe that working to benefit society maximizes individual
happiness.
According to a Humanist
Magazine, "Humanism is a rational philosophy informed by science, inspired
by art, and motivated by compassion. It derives its goals of life from human
needs and interest rather than from theological or ideological abstractions and
asserts that humanity must take responsibility for its destiny." Many
prominent scientists, Nobel laureates, doctors, philosophers, authors, and
scholars who are humanists subscribe to the ideologies of rationalism, atheism,
or agnosticism. They seem to have a sincere concern for human welfare and believe
in the human ability to solve human problems without any help from supernatural
powers.
Valluvar and Humanism
Valluvar
and religion: Valluvar does mention God in some of the kurals.
In kural 1, he mentions that God is first in this world, just as the letter
"A "is first in the alphabet. Although he does not explicitly state
that God created this world, this kural is interpreted by many commentators to
imply Valluvar's faith in God as the Creator. In kural 5, Valluvar says that
the good and evil consequences arising from the actions based on the darkness
of illusion (ignorance) shall not impact those who delight in the praise of
God. In kural 2, he asks, "What does one gain from all the learning if one
does not worship the good feet of Him who is the personification of pure
knowledge?" Valluvar also believes in the existence of a soul, which takes
a series of incarnations. In fact, he says that death is like sleep, and birth
is the awakening from it (kural - 339). He wonders whether there is no permanent
place for the soul, which leaves the body at the time of death like the
fledgling that flees its nest when it is ready to fly (kural – 340). The kurals
339 and 340 imply that the human soul is permanent, and the human body is only
a temporary abode for the human soul. Like sleep and awakening, a soul keeps
taking incarnations one after the other. Valluvar offers two solutions to sever
the chain of births and deaths. In kural 10, he says that those who become
united with God will be able to cross the ocean of births and deaths (kural –
10). In kural 349, he opines that in order to be free from future births, one
should eliminate all attachments that arise out of desires. There are also
other kurals that point to Valluvar's beliefs in God, soul, and reincarnation.
It
is clear that Valluvar believes in God, and he also believes in the permanence
of the human soul and that it undergoes an unending sequence of incarnations. These
beliefs of Valluvar are not based on any of the three religions (Vedic
Brahmanism, Buddhism, and Jainism) that existed during his period. He differs
significantly from the three religions of his time. These are his own beliefs
based on his own reasoning. In view of his own faith-based beliefs, Valluvar
cannot be considered an atheist or an agnostic. However, since his views do not
represent any particular religion and due to the fact that he does not advocate
any specific religion, Valluvar can be considered a secular philosopher who is
an independent thinker.
Valluvar
and rationalism: Rationalism is a belief or
a theory that opinions and actions should be based on reason and knowledge
rather than on religious beliefs or emotional responses. Obviously, since
atheists and agnostics do not have any religious beliefs, they support
rationalism and consider it the methodology for arriving at the truth. However,
it should be mentioned that rationalism does not help to explain or understand
everything. It has its own limitations. For example, if a rationalist is asked,
"Where did the universe come from?" his response would be, "It
came as a result of the Big Bang, which occurred about 14 billion years
ago." However, at present, rationalists and cosmologists do not have any
answers to questions like, "Why did the Big Bang occur?", "What
was there before the Big Bang?" Anthropologists estimate that human beings
have been living on earth for almost 200,000 years. So, it has taken nearly
200,000 years to come up with the Big Bang theory. Therefore, it is uncertain
if and when science can offer additional explanations to unravel the mysteries
of the universe. Also, it is quite likely that there could always be a question
to which science may not have an answer. Therefore, when it comes to questions
like the universe and its origin, an ordinary individual has three options. One
option is to take the answers provided by science and wait for science to come
up with further explanations. The second option is to be completely indifferent
and ignore such questions as irrelevant. The third option is to assume that
there has to be a Creator who is omnipotent and responsible for all that is
created. From a practical standpoint, all three options are equally valid and
viable. From the Kural, it appears that Valluvar believes in the last of the
three options mentioned above.
Believing in God does not imply that one cannot be rational in other
areas of investigations. For example, in the past, there have been several
well-known scientists who believed in a Creator and perhaps even belonged to a
religion of their choice. Even now, there are many scientists who believe in
God or a higher power. According to a survey of scientists who are members of
the American Association for the Advancement of Science conducted in 2009 by
the Pew Research Center, a non-partisan fact tank located in Washington D. C.,
51% of scientists believed in God or a universal spirit or a higher power. In
fact, 33% of the scientists believed in God, and 18% believed in a universal
spirit or a higher power. Their religious beliefs do not seem to cloud their
scientific thinking. Similarly, in the case of Valluvar, his belief in God does
not hinder his ability to have a rational outlook on other matters. For example,
he insists, "Whatever be the apparent nature of things, it is wise to
investigate their true nature (kural – 355)." Free inquiry into the nature
of things is the basis of science. Valluvar's suggestion that one should investigate
the true nature of things is entirely compatible with rational thinking and scientific
methodologies. He also states, "True wisdom is to discern the truth in
whatever is said by whomsoever (kural – 423)." The idea behind this kural
is somewhat similar to that of kural 355. Based on kural 423, one can conclude
that Valluvar is open to the inquiry of all statements made by anyone. A
typical religious person would not be open to questioning his own religious
dogmas. Since Valluvar does not endorse any religion as the ultimate truth, he
is open to the inquiry of all statements made by anyone. According to him,
individuals should investigate and believe whatever they feel comfortable with
and should not blindly follow any faith. The kurals mentioned above are
consistent with the humanists' philosophy that "No beliefs should be
considered off-limits and be protected from rational scrutiny."
Valluvar and Human Effort
Humanists
depend upon their effort to accomplish their objectives. Since they do not believe
in God or other supernatural powers, they do not expect any help from such non-existent
entities. Most religious people believe in the human effort as a necessary
requirement for achieving their objectives. They may believe that total
reliance on human effort alone may not be sufficient. They may believe in the
power of prayer and hope that praying to God may help to accomplish their
objectives. Of course, this is entirely a question of personal preference based
on one's convictions. As mentioned before, Valluvar believes in God. But
despite his belief in God, he emphasizes determination, dedication, and
persistent hard work as the necessary factors to accomplish one's objectives in
life. He does not mention prayer as a prerequisite for accomplishing one's
objectives in worldly affairs. His emphasis is on self-reliance rather than on
religious beliefs. He says, "One should not feel disheartened when a task
seems impossible; persistent efforts will lead to greatness (kural –
611)." He also believes that persistent hard work will bring about good
fortune, and indolence will bring about poverty (kural – 616). Valluvar is
pragmatic, and he realizes that despite persistent hard work, there may be
unforeseen random events that could interfere with one's ability to accomplish
one's objectives. He says, "What is more powerful than unpredictable
random events (fate)? Even if one plans to overcome them, they will interfere
with one's plans (kural – 380)." Although he realizes the inevitability of
unexpected interruptions to one's plans, Valluvar believes, "People who
work hard with ceaseless industry will overcome the obstacles created by the
unpredictable random events (kural -
620)." Valluvar's proposed solution to all adversities and obstacles on
the path to success is to laugh at them and face them boldly. He says, "Laugh at adversity; there is
nothing better than laughter to overcome adversity (kural – 621)." In
addition to offering encouragement and support for persistent hard work, he
also says, "Even if gods do not help you, your hard work will certainly be
rewarded (kural – 619)." So, it is clear that Valluvar's advice to achieve
success in life is self-reliance and hard work and not prayer. Valluvar's
emphasis on hard work rather than dependence on prayer is similar to the
humanist philosophy of self-reliance.
Valluvar and moral values: Moral values are
discussed throughout the Kural. However, the section on Virtue is entirely
dedicated to moral values and ethical behavior. Valluvar's ideas on virtue can
be grouped into two major categories. One is the set of ideas which are about
behaviors and practices that one should avoid. The other is the set of ideas
about the pursuit of positive behaviors and practices intended to help others
without expecting anything in return.
Valluvar believes in the equality of all human
beings. He denounces the prevalent class system during his period and declares
that all are equal by birth. In fact, he declares," All human beings are equal by birth, but distinctions arise only
because of the different qualities of their actions (kural – 972)." He insists that everyone should have empathy for his fellow human
beings. He wonders, "If one cannot treat others' sufferings as his own,
what benefit has one gained from his intelligence (kural – 315)?" He cannot comprehend "Why does a man inflict upon other
living beings those things he found harmful to himself (kural – 318)?"
Valluvar's idea of nonviolence is reminiscent of the so-called Golden Rule, which states, "Do
not do unto others what you don't want others to do unto you." Although
this version of the Golden Rule is attributed to the Chinese Philosopher
Confucius, this moral axiom appears in various forms in the writings of almost every
culture and religion throughout history. It must be mentioned that Valluvar
goes above and beyond the Golden Rule when he suggests, "The proper
punishment for the one who has done evil to you is to do him something good in return
and make him feel ashamed of himself (kural – 314)." According to Valluvar, "It is the supreme virtue
not to have a harmful thought about anybody in any degree at any moment (kural
317)." Since thought precedes words and deeds, if one does not have an
evil thought in his mind, then he would not hurt others' feelings by uttering
harsh words and harm others by his actions.
According to humanists, moral and ethical values are derived from human
needs and interests as tested by experience, and they should not be based on
religious values. For example, humanists are in total agreement with the Golden Rule. In the view of Greg M. Epstein, a Humanist Chaplain at Harvard
University, "The Golden Rule is a concept that essentially no
religion misses entirely. But not even one of these versions of the golden
rule requires a God." Likewise,
Valluvar's ideas regarding equality, empathy, avoiding evil thoughts, harsh
words, and harmful deeds towards others are based on socially acceptable good conduct
rules. They are not based on religious mandates. From his point of view,
they represent acceptable and ethical human behavior, and they are the right
code of conduct in the interest of the individual and society. So, Valluvar's
views on moral values are completely consistent with those of the humanists.
Humanitarianism
Humanitarianism can be
defined as an ethical doctrine that emphasizes concern and action towards human
welfare and social reform. A true humanitarian strives to promote human welfare
and social reforms and has no prejudice based on gender, sexual orientation,
religion, or race. A humanitarian's goal is to save lives, relieve suffering,
provide food and shelter, and medical assistance for the poor, homeless, and needy
out of kindness and compassion. In the course of human history, there have been
many humanitarians. They have either contributed large sums of money or personally
engaged in services aimed at eradicating diseases, feeding the poor, providing
medical assistance to the needy, educating the underprivileged, etc. Although
the humanists have humanitarianism as one of their basic principles, the
humanitarians are the ones who seem to put the principles into practice. Unlike
the humanists, the humanitarians are not necessarily atheists or agnostics.
Religious affiliation is neither a necessity nor a hindrance to one's
humanitarian pursuits. In the case of some humanitarians, religion can motivate
them to dedicate their lives and resources to humanitarian projects in
anticipation of benefits in the other world.
Valluvar emphasizes the
importance of love and compassion in several kurals. He says, "Love is the
quintessence of life; without it, a man is nothing but a frame of bones covered
with skin (kural 80)." He adds, "The soul is linked with the body
because of its inborn relationship with love (kural – 73)." In other
words, he contends that love towards fellow human beings is an inherent human
emotion in a human being. But this inherent noble emotion in the human mind is
often hidden and suppressed by the pollutants like envy, covetousness, anger,
greed, etc. According to Valluvar, "Having a mind free of pollutants (blemishes
or impure thoughts) is the true virtue; all else is an empty show (kural –
34)." Valluvar encourages his readers to recognize this and develop a mind
which is free of pollutants and follow the path of love. He is of the opinion
that "Those who are destitute of love will keep everything to themselves,
but those who possess love will give even their bones to others (kural
72)." In Valluvar's scheme of things, compassion is an outgrowth of love.
Love and compassion motivate one to share his food, wealth, and all resources
at his disposal with others who are in need.
In addition to love and
compassion, Valluvar firmly believes in the equality of all human beings. He is
also convinced that intelligence in a human being should evoke a feeling of
empathy for others' sufferings. The combination of love, compassion, a feeling
of equality, and empathy for others' sufferings makes one a natural
humanitarian. It is this humanitarian feeling of Valluvar that manifests itself
in the form of his insistence on hospitality even towards strangers, sharing
one's resources with others who need help.
During the days of
Valluvar, there were no hotels or restaurants where travelers could stay or
feed themselves during the course of their travels. Valluvar strongly recommends
that hospitality towards travelers - even if they are strangers - is the duty
of a householder. He says, "The purpose of leading a family life is to
entertain (provide food and shelter) guests (kural – 81)." He adds,
"Even if you were consuming the nectar of immortality, you should share it
with your guests (kural – 82)." It should be noted that in the terminology
of the Kural, guests refer to strangers and not relatives.
Valluvar considers charity
and munificence as two essential virtues to be practiced by everyone. According
to him, "Giving to the needy alone is real charity; all the rest is an
investment in anticipation of a return (kural – 221)." To him, an act of
charity is something that one should do out of compassion and kindness. He
insists that an act of charity has to be carried out even if there is no
heavenly reward (kural – 222). Valluvar attaches so much importance to charity
that he says, "Nothing is more painful than death; even death will be
sweet if one finds himself unable to relieve the distress of others (kural –
230). "
In addition to charity,
Valluvar also proposes that one should practice munificence. Charity is a way
of helping someone who asks for help. Munificence refers to acts of generosity aimed
at a large number of people. Valluvar's emphasis on munificence is evident when
he says, "All the wealth gained from hard work is to serve the deserving
others (kural - 212)." Valluvar’s model for munificence is the rain-bearing
cloud. He says, “Munificence does not expect anything in return. What can the
world give back in return to the rain-bearing clouds (kural -211)?” In Valluvar’s opinion, “Only those who know
and practice munificence are the ones who can be considered as truly living;
others will be reckoned with the dead (kural - 214).”
Valluvar considers that
the humanitarian acts of hospitality, charity, and munificence result from
love, kindness, compassion, and empathy, and they are not religious mandates.
They are to be done without expecting any reward in this world or in the next
world.
Conclusion
In the absence of any reliable biographic information, one
cannot say anything with absolute certainty about the personal life of
Valluvar. But, based on his work, we can
arrive at some logical conclusions. In kural 819, Valluvar says, “Association
with those whose words and deeds do not match is bitter even in dreams.” Since he stresses the need for consistency
between one’s words and deeds, it is reasonable to assume that his behavior
would have been consistent with his philosophy. He can be considered a secular
humanist based on his secular outlook, advocacy for rationalism, emphasis on
self-reliance, insistence on human efforts, and love of humanity. His emphasis on
hospitality, charity, and munificence is a testament to his humanitarianism.
So, it is reasonable to conclude that Valluvar must have been a secular
humanist who was also a humanitarian extraordinaire.
References:
Stephen Law. Humanism: A Very Short Introduction. Oxford University
Press, Oxford, UK. 2011
http://americanhumanist.org/Humanism/Definitions_of_Humanism
http://wwwpewforum.org/2009/11/05/scientists-and-belief/
Chuck Feeney (1931 - ): Charles Francis "Chuck" Feeney founder of Duty Free Shops has contributed millions of dollars to universities and hospitals. He is an Irish-American businessman and philanthropist and the founder of The Atlantic Philanthropies, one of the largest private foundations in the world. The board of his foundation has instructions to give away every penny of his 8 billion dollar fortune by 2016.